Authors: Da Zhu (RGL Reservoir Management Inc.) | Gary Bunio (Suncor Energy) | Ian D. Gates (University of Calgary)
The main challenges faced by oil sands operators are the cost of operations and the environmental intensity of the recovery processes. The Athabasca oil sands deposit contains bitumen with viscosity typically over 1 million cP. To lower the viscosity of the bitumen so that it can be drained from these reservoirs, it is heated with injected steam by using Steam-Assisted Gravity Drainage (SAGD). This process is effective and enables recovery factors over 60%. The major cost in the recovery process is steam generation and associated water treatment and handling. The combustion of natural gas to generate steam is the main origin of the carbon dioxide emissions associated with SAGD. An alternative to steam injection is the use of solvents co-injected with steam. Solvents dilute bitumen leading to an oil phase with reduced viscosity. Also, there is potential to recycle solvent for re-injection. Thus, solvent added to steam can improve the steam-to-oil ratio and as a consequence can lower the carbon dioxide emissions per unit volume oil produced. In this extended abstract, we describe a phased solvent and heat process that yields improved performance beyond that of SAGD and current solvent-aided SAGD processes.
Download paper
Authors: Mahdi Mahmoudi (University of Alberta) | Vahidoddin Fattahpour (University of Alberta) | Alireza Nouri (University of Alberta) | Ting Yao (the University of Hong Kong) | Beatrice Anne Baudet (the University of Hong Kong) | Michael Leitch (RGL Reservoir Management Inc.) | Brent Fermaniuk (RGL Reservoir Management Inc.)
This paper presents the results of several large-scale Sand Retention Tests (SRTs), which are used to test and refine the criteria used for slotted liner design. The paper also presents the analysis of test measurements to improve the understanding of the parameters that influence the sand control performance. The parameters include Particle Size Distribution (PSD), flow rate, slot opening size and slot density.
The SRT facility was commissioned to improve the existing testing methods by (1) using multiple-slot rather than single-slot coupons, (2) using more realistic sand pack preparation/saturation procedures than the existing practices, (3) measuring the pressure drop along the sand pack and across the liner coupon to assess the retained permeability and flow convergence, and (4) post-mortem analysis of the sand pack to measure fines/clay content along the sand pack as a direct measure of fines migration. Several tests were performed by varying the slot size, slot density, and PSD of the sand pack, and flow rate. The testing data were used to validate and improve the current industrial design of slotted liners.
Test measurements and observations indicate that the sand pack preparation procedure highly affects the testing results. For typical field porosities and PSDs, we observed finite amount of sand production bellow the existing criteria for sanding during the SRT, for the screens designed based on existing models. Testing data also indicate smaller retained permeability for lower slot density due to converging flow. Moreover, measurements indicate lower retained permeability for narrower slot width, caused by the accumulation of fines and pore plugging in the liner’s vicinity. However, larger slot width than a certain size contributes to higher levels of sanding. Three different sanding modes are identified: (1) initial sanding or sand occurrence, (2) flow rate dependent transient and (3) flow rate dependent continuous sanding. It is proposed that the sanding mode should be also included in the design criteria along with the acceptable sanding threshold. Test results indicate the combined effect of the slot size and density on both retained permeability and sand production. These findings lead to a new design approach for maximum retained permeability and acceptable sand retention.
This paper introduces a new set of design criteria for slotted liners based on the results of a novel large-scale testing to evaluate the sand control for thermal heavy oil production applications. Also it provides a better understanding of the sand production and the role of the slot width and slot density on the sand production. The paper also presents an improved understanding of the sanding and permeability evolution close to the liner in relation to several liners and flow parameters. The set-up, testing procedures, and measurement methods that are used in the experiments improve the existing methods in several fronts.
Download paper
Authors: Vahidoddin Fattahpour (University of Alberta) | Saman Azadbakht (University of Alberta) | Mahdi Mahmoudi (University of Alberta) | Yujia Guo (University of Alberta) | Alireza Nouri (University of Alberta) | Michael Leitch (RGL Reservoir Management Inc.)
In SAGD wells, the gap between the oil sand and the sand control liner closes or collapses over time due to such factors as the oil sand thermal expansion, the melting of bitumen and the ensuing loss of the apparent bonding between the grains. The result is the buildup of effective stresses and the gradual compaction of the oil sands around the liner. Current practices for the sand control design do not account for the effect of time-dependent effective stress variation around the liner on the sand control performance. In this paper, we outline the results of an experimental study on the effect of near-liner effective stress on the performance of slotted liners.
This study builds on existing experimental procedures and investigates fines migration, sand production and clogging tendency of slotted liner coupons in large-scale unconsolidated sand-packs. Sand-packs with controlled properties (grain size distribution, grain shape, and mineralogy) are packed on a multi-slot sand control coupon in a triaxial cell assembly. Varying levels of stress are applied to the sand-packs in directions parallel and perpendicular to the multi-slot coupon. For each stress level, brine is injected into the sand-pack from the top surface of the sample towards the coupon. Test measurements include pressure drops across the sand-pack and the coupon as well as the produced sand/fines mass for each stress level. Post-mortem analysis is performed to measure fines/clay concentration along the sand-pack as a direct measure of fines migration.
Experimental results show that under the subsequent increase in effective stresses, sand-packs experience considerable deformations in directions parallel and perpendicular to the multi-slot coupon; which result in a drastic drop in the porosity and retained permeability. Test results show that the maximum reduction in permeability occurs in the vicinity of the multi-slot coupons due to the fines accumulation and the higher compaction in that region. In comparison to experiments with no confining stress, the application of confining stress results in lower retained permeability in the sand-packs as well as reduced sand production.
This paper presents, for the first time, the effect of near wellbore effective stress on clogging tendency and sand retention characteristics of slotted liner completions. The tests allow the assessment of the adequacy of the use of existing design criteria over the life cycle of the well under variable stress conditions around the liner.
Download paper
Authors: Mahdi Mahmoudi (University of Alberta) | Vahidoddin Fattahpour (University of Alberta) | Alireza Nouri (University of Alberta) | Saad Rasoul (University of Alberta) | Ting Yao (The University of Hong Kong) | Beatrice Anne Baudet (The University of Hong Kong) | Michael Leitch (RGL Reservoir Management Inc.) | Mohammad Soroush (University of Trinidad and Tobago)
This paper presents the characterization of oil sands from the McMurray Formation. The main objective of this paper is to investigate the possibility of replicating the oil sands by the mixtures of commercial sands and fines for large-scale testing. There is a growing interest in large-scale evaluation testing for sand control devices that require considerable amounts of representative oil sands materials. However, natural representative oil sands samples are usually not available or are limited in quantity. Therefore, replicating the oil sands is essential for such tests.
Twenty-three oil sands samples were collected from two wells in the McMurray Formation and cleaned using the Soxhlet extraction technique. The cleaned samples were examined using the image analysis technique and Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM) imaging to study their Particle Size Distribution (PSD), shape factors, mineralogy, and texture. Similar analysis was performed on eleven series of commercial sands to compare their shape, mineralogy, and texture with those of oil sands. Particle Size Distribution of 10 commercial fines was also analyzed with a particle sizer to cover the required fine/clay part of the duplicated samples. Direct shear and 1D consolidation were performed to compare the mechanical properties of the oil sands samples and the duplicated mixtures of commercial sands and fines.
The shape factors of the oil sand and the selected commercial sand samples are in close agreement. In addition to the common average/cumulative shape factor measurements, this paper also presents the variation of shape factors within each sample for different grain sizes. The results show the same sand shape characteristics among all oil sand samples as well as the tested commercial sands. Further, XRD results indicate a similar mineralogy for the commercial sands and the oil sands samples. The SEM images show random changes in the surface texture of both oil sands and commercial sands with no observable trends. We were able to use commercial sands and fines mixture with similar grain shape properties to duplicate the PSD of the oil sand samples. Direct shear and 1D consolidation testing of the oil sands and samples made of commercial sands and fines show similar consolidation and frictional properties for both the duplicated mixture and cleaned oil sands for the same compaction level (porosities).
This paper provides a procedure for duplicating the oil sands with commercial sands and fines. It also provides detailed information on the mineralogy, texture, and the variation of the shape characteristics for oil sands from the McMurray Formation.
Download paper
Authors: Fattahpour, Vahidoddin & Mahmoudi, Mahdi & Nouri, Alireza & Leitch, Michael.
Several sand control techniques have been used in SAGD wells in Western Canada. For most projects, slotted liner has been the sand control of choice for its economics, ease of use, and acceptable performance. Careful design of the slot geometry is crucial to maintain long term wellbore performance but is not an easy task in formations with high fines content and other challenging characteristics, such as in Grand Rapids or shore-face at the upper member of McMurray. The objective in the design of sand control is generally to minimize the production of sand and maximize the retained permeability in the liner’s vicinity by allowing the production of any mobilized fines, avoiding extreme pressure drops by minimizing the curvature of flow streamlines around the slots, and avoiding the plugging of slots over time. Design practices for sand control in SAGD wells are currently based mostly on Particle Size Distribution (PSD) and the fines (<44um) content. Where designers focus principally on retaining sand rather than maximizing the retained permeability in the liner’s vicinity, there is an increased risk of underperforming completion designs, but long term well performance requires a reasonable tolerance for solids production. This paper provides a critical review of existing design criteria and the experimental testing and techniques for assessing the sand control design for SAGD production wells. It reviews the mechanisms which cause sand production and fines migration in relation to the PSD of oil sands and the formation clay and silt content. In addition, the paper presents field failure cases from the literature and examines the common problems with different types of sand control. Finally, practical recommendations are presented to further improve the current design criteria and sand control experiments to achieve higher productivity index, lower skin buildup, and greater durability of sand control screens.
Download paper
Authors: Mahdi Mahmoudi, University of Alberta; Vahidoddin Fattahpour, University of Alberta; Alireza Nouri, University of Alberta; Saad Rasool, University of Alberta; Michael Leitch, RGL Reservoir Management Inc.
The quantification of fines migration in the vicinity of sand control screens in SAGD wells is of paramount importance to operating companies, who require the wells to operate under optimum conditions for a period of 10-15 years. Fines migration can lead to the plugging of pore spaces around the liner and result in reduced permeability in the liner’s vicinity, hence, lowering the wellbore productivity. This paper investigates the fines migration in relation to slot width and density in SAGD wells. A series of laboratory experiments was performed by using a Sand Retention Testing (SRT) facility which accommodates a sand pack sample and a multi-slot coupon to represent the near-wellbore high-porosity zone and sand control liner, respectively. As fluid was pumped through the sand pack and across the slotted coupon, the pressure drop across the sand pack and coupon was measured, along with the mass and Particle Size Distribution (PSD) of produced fines and sand. After the flow test, the sand pack was dissected, and the PSD of fines portion of sand pack was measured to assess the movement and concentration of fines over the course of the test. Test observations indicate that the slot width, slot density, and the flow rate highly affect the fines migration/production and the PSD of the migrated and produced fines. Larger slot widths increase the mass of the produced and migrated fines. Further observations indicate that the mass and size of produced fines is highly dependent on the flow rate and that there is a critical rate below which little amounts of fines are produced or move in the porous medium.
Download paper
Authors: Mahdi Mahmoudi (University of Alberta) | Vahidoddin Fattahpour (University of Alberta) | Alireza Nouri (University of Alberta) | Michael Leitch (RGL Reservoir Management Inc.)
In this paper, we present the results of an experimental investigation on the effect of pH and salinity on slotted liner performance in terms of sanding and retained permeability for heavy oil thermal production. This work is an advancement of the existing knowledge in the literature which indicates that pH and salinity could highly affect the mobilization, flocculation and deflocculating of clays (mainly Illite and Kaolinite) in oil sands formations.
Water with different pH, in the range of 6.8 to 8.8, and salinities, in the range of 0 to 1.4 % was injected into sand pack samples supported with multi-slot coupon in a Sand Retention Testing (SRT) facility. Measurements included pressure drops along the sand pack and across the slotted liner coupon as well as the produced sand/fines for different flow rates. These measurements were used to assess the effect of the pH and salinity on fines migration within the sand pack, capability of the slotted liner to produce the fines, pore and slot plugging, sand production and the retained permeability.
We observed that the pressure drops, fines production and the retained permeability are highly dependent on the pH and salinity of the injected fluid. In low pH and high salinity environment, clay is not mobilized resulting in low pressure drops and high retained permeabilities. On the other hand, an increase in pH value or a decrease in salinity leads to significant clay mobilization and a remarkable reduction in retained permeability.
This paper provides a thorough experimental investigation of the pH and salinity effect on slotted liner performance. The effect of the pH and salinity is usually ignored in screen control testing while it could highly control the clay mobilization and retained permeability. Results of this study could trigger wide reconsideration in sand control approaches particularly by altering the pH in the near wellbore zone.
Download paper
Authors: Li, Lei & Lange, Carlos & Ma, Yongsheng.
Outflow Control Device (OCD) is applied in Steam Assisted Gravity Drainage (SAGD) to control the steam split to the formation from the injection well. The detailed analysis of OCD with CFD is desired to obtain comprehensive understanding of the flow in the device and guide design optimization. The simulation presented here is based on a commercial OCD product applied in industry. With ANSYS/CFX TM , the simulation research was carried out by phases. According to the analysis of OCD application conditions, the simulation of a small quarter domain is conducted to test the boundary conditions and the OCD flow behavior corresponding to different pressure drops. The steam distribution is believed to have an effect on the efficiency of heating. To evaluate the effect of different design on steam distribution, the simulation of half domain with different gap sizes was further processed; two parameters have been identified to quantify the steam distribution. A simulation scenario of a 360°domain is introduced at last to discover the interaction between the steam flowing through the four orifices.
Download paper
Authors: Da Zhu (RGL Reservoir Management Inc.) | Jacky Wang (University of Calgary) | Yi Su (University of Calgary) | Ian D. Gates (University of Calgary)
Numerical simulators have been extensively used in reservoir engineering for several decades. These simulators, based on energy, material, and momentum (multiphase Darcy law) balances and thermodynamic equilibrium of components between phases, solve a coupled set of nonlinear partial differential equations. We have observed multiple states for simulation of Steam-Assisted Gravity Drainage (SAGD) with multiple steam-to-oil ratios resulting at the same steam injection rate. The existence of multiple solutions and potentially limit cycle behavior and its associated bifurcation branching in the operation parameter space inspires us to consider a dynamical approach to reservoir simulation. There are four dominant states of stability: absolutely stable; neutrally stable; unstable subject to infinitesimal perturbation; and unstable subject to finite amplitude perturbation. In essence, instability is a process that releases potential energy stored in the base state to the perturbation state. In a reservoir simulation, if we impose a perturbation with a certain magnitude to a quasi-steady state, linear stability theory predicts that once the system becomes unstable, the magnitude of the perturbation grows with time infinitely. However, in reality, due to nonlinearity the system causes it to evolve to a new quasi-steady state. The questions that we are going to address in this paper are: How can we use a transient reservoir simulator to detect instability of the system that may lead to different and multiple operating states? As a case study, we will use a 2D homogeneous SAGD model. Once the model reaches a quasi-steady state, we will call it our base state. Then we impose different steam injection rate perturbations on the system and see how the system responds to these changes. Different behaviors result –for finite amplitude perturbations, the state evolves to a new state (Hopf bifurcation) (Strogatz 2014). Our goal is to use an existing commercial simulator to construct multiple operating states and describe an approach to detect them. Multiple operating states could have significant implications for process control and risk/uncertainty management of reservoir operations.
Download paper
Authors: Lei Li, Yongsheng Ma, Carlos F. Lange
CFD (Computational Fluid Dynamics) requires strong expertise and extensive training to obtain accurate results. To improve the usability in the complex product development process, two new types of engineering features, fluid physics feature and dynamic physics feature, which convey the simulation intent, are proposed in this paper to achieve CFD solver setup automation and robust simulation model generation in an ideal CAD/CAE integration system. Further, the association between simulation intent and design intent is integrated with another newly defined fluid functional feature in order to achieve the consistency. Consequently, an optimal design could be achieved by considering production operation, manufacturability and cost analysis concurrently. A case study of steam assisted gravity drainage (SAGD) outflow control device (OCD) is presented to show the prospective benefits of the method.
Download paper